May 2003

Veto Override

From the NYS Assembly • Sheldon Silver, Speaker
Herman D. Farrell, Jr. • Chair, Ways and Means Committee
What experts are saying...

"Legislative leaders Sheldon Silver and Joseph Bruno made the better choice. They passed a historic bipartisan budget that protects healthcare and our children’s education."

- Dennis Rivera, President, 1199/SEIU, New York’s Health & Human Service Union

"Senator Bruno and Speaker Silver should be praised for this courageous act. The Legislature has made a ‘better choice’ for all New Yorkers. These are extraordinary times and they call for extraordinary measures. We applaud the Legislature for rising above politics and ideology and for putting the needs of the state above all else."

- Denis Hughes, President, New York State AFL-CIO

"It is clear that real New Yorkers understand that the budget the governor proposed would have undermined the quality of life in this state by killing jobs, destroying necessary services and slamming local school and property taxpayers."

- Danny Donohue, President, Civil Services Employees Association

"Despite facing very difficult decisions, these courageous lawmakers prevented cuts that would have forced health care providers to lay off staff, cut programs and services, or even close. ... Health care providers are extraordinarily grateful for these restorations."

- Daniel Sisto, President, Healthcare Association of New York State

"Our 2.5 million AARP members in New York State are grateful to the Legislature for restoring this critical funding for the elderly. The current budget bills are a big relief to the older New Yorkers and their families who depend on these programs."

- Lois Aronstein, New York State Director, AARP

"The Assembly and Senate have adopted a balanced approach to supporting public education that maintains the state as a full partner with local communities."

- Timothy Kremer, Executive Director, New York State School Boards Association

"What is also important about New York’s legislative budget is that it spares local governments huge increases in their property taxes."

- New York Times editorial, May 2, 2003

"...It is the Legislature that has made the right choices this year. Overriding the governor’s vetoes will confirm that choice."

- The Journal News editorial, May 15, 2003

"School district leaders appreciate the Assembly and Senate’s efforts to prioritize education funding. Although a small cut remains, the $1 billion that the Legislature has added will help school districts restore valuable programs for children and lessen the impact on local taxpayers."

- Tom Rogers, Executive Director, New York State Council of School Superintendents

"...Senator Bruno and Assembly Speaker Silver restored the majority of the governor’s school aid cuts, clearly recognizing that maintaining vital school programs and staving off radical property tax increases were New Yorkers’ highest priorities this year."\

- Regina Eaton, Executive Director, Alliance for Quality Education

Legislature makes the right choice —

Stands Up to the Governor’s Budget Cuts and Tax Hikes

The Legislature stood firm in its commitment to the people of New York, overriding the governor’s veto and delivering a fair, responsible budget for New York’s families.

Legislators from across party lines could plainly see the devastation the governor’s budget cuts would cause working families. Time and again, the Legislature asked the governor to show leadership and make the right choices. Instead, he refused to negotiate and vetoed the Legislature’s bipartisan budget accord – stubbornly insisting on a budget that would impose the largest property tax increase in history, and threaten quality education and affordable health care.

Saving our schools – protecting our future

Year after year, the governor tries to slash education spending, and year after year, the Assembly restores it. In fact, prior to this year, the Assembly has successfully restored $2.8 billion of the governor’s education cuts.

This year is no different. The governor wanted to cut $1.4 billion from schools. The Assembly and Senate came together to make a better choice, restoring $1.1 billion for the coming school year. As a result, effective education programs will be spared and school districts will get the help they need to stave off the massive property tax hikes, teacher layoffs, and program cuts that many districts faced under Governor Pataki’s proposal.

Because of the restorations, universal pre-kindergarten and full-day kindergarten – both of which are cited by experts as critical in a student’s development – will be saved, as will class size reduction initiatives and after-school programs.

Protecting quality, affordable health care

Under the governor’s plan, the state’s health care system faced funding cuts of more than $2 billion – a body blow to an already reeling industry. In addition to jeopardizing quality care, the governor’s proposal could have jeopardized 48,000 jobs in the health care industry – New York’s largest employer.

Again, the Legislature stepped up to block another bad choice from the governor, restoring $1.2 billion in state funds for Medicaid, public health, and Health Care Reform Act programs. These restorations will ensure that many New Yorkers will continue to receive the quality, affordable care they need.

Specifically, the Legislature’s bipartisan plan:

  • protects vital county health organizations, our frontline defense against emerging diseases like SARS and potential bioterror attacks;
  • keeps open the psychiatric and research institutes across the state that the governor wanted to shutter;
  • allows adult day care, meals for seniors, and Alzheimer’s initiatives to keep providing valuable services;
  • reinstates funding for Breast Cancer Support and Education Services that the governor wanted cut;
  • delivers the $14 monthly federal Supplemental Security Income cost-of-living adjustment, which the governor wanted to deny low-income seniors and the disabled;
  • protects seniors from the governor’s fee increases in the Elderly Pharmaceutical Insurance Program;
  • restores more than $5.5 million for AIDS programs that the governor wanted to cut;
  • restores $252,000 of the governor’s cuts to Rape Crisis Services; and
  • restores $27 million the governor wanted to take from the pockets of state retirees and employees for higher health insurance premiums.

Creating a more competitive workforce through higher education

The governor’s budget would have been disastrous for our state colleges and universities, affecting both the students attending them in hopes of building a better future and the local economies that depend on them. Under the administration’s original plan, SUNY and CUNY students would have seen their tuitions rise $1,400, the Tuition Assistance Program cut by a third, and opportunity programs cut in half. Base aid to community colleges also would have fallen by $345 per student, forcing property tax hikes and tuition increases.

Rather than joining the governor in undermining the educational foundations of our burgeoning high-tech economy, the Legislature restored the cuts to TAP, opportunity programs and community college base aid, and rolled back the governor’s proposed tuition increase by a third. All in all, nearly $400 million was restored to higher education.

Building a stronger economy

Over the past nine years, New York has suffered because of the governor’s failed economic development policies. Even at the height of the nation’s economic boom in the late ‘90s, he failed to adequately capitalize on our assets. In fact, had we created jobs in New York at the same rate as the rest of the country during that time, we would have 476,000 more jobs statewide – as many jobs as there are people in the entire state of Wyoming.

This year is no different, as once again, the governor has failed to provide the state with the leadership we need to move our state forward. Even worse, his budget proposal would have cut $3.5 million from the Assembly’s Empire Zone program, which his administration acknowledged is the most successful economic development program in the history of the state. Once again, it fell upon the Legislature to undo the governor’s wrong choice, restoring more than $2.3 million of his cut, protecting this vital program and the jobs it creates.

In addition, we rejected $268.9 million in new fees, fines and assessments in his budget, and lowered a tax on nursing homes to save them $45 million in the current year. We also refused to go along with his plan to raise the state sales tax by a whopping 31 percent – a proposal that was his only attempt to amend his wrong-headed budget choices.

Legislature will continue working to move New York forward

Recognizing the seriousness of New York’s budget crisis, the Assembly and Senate put aside partisan differences to do what’s right for the people of our state. The governor’s unwillingness to come up with better solutions to the budget crisis was a disappointment, but he can still exercise his leadership role in this state. The Legislature will continue working to address the many issues facing our state in a serious and responsible manner, and we will remain open to working and cooperating with the governor. The governor need not continue standing in the way of progress. We need him to join with us to move New York forward.

The Assembly Internet Information Service is available to those interested in receiving timely legislative updates by e-mail.
To subscribe to this service, please drop us a line at, indicating your area of interest. (The Assembly Internet Information Service will not release, sell or give away a subscriber’s e-mail address, name or any other information provided without express permission from the subscriber. Each e-mail notice or newsletter will contain simple instructions for removing your name from the mailing list if you decide you no longer wish to subscribe.)

New York State Assembly
[ Welcome Page ] [ Committee Updates ]